Voice of America
19 May 2023, 00:36 GMT+10
Amman, Jordan - Some analysts in the Middle East argue that concerns over China's rapid military modernization and technology competition are pulling Washington's attention away from the Mideast region. While the United States may not be the only global player in the region, others say its retreat from the Middle East is a myth.
Analysts see security and energy issues, Israel, and Iran's nuclear threat as key issues for U.S. policy in the Middle East. As James Phillips of the Washington-based Heritage Foundation and others see it, Washington is pressing regional allies to assume more responsibility for their own defense. "Nervous Arab Gulf states are hedging and cultivating closer ties to China and Russia; Iran and Turkey are absorbing parts of Iraq and Syria, two [practically] failed states," he told GIS reports.
Jennifer Kavanagh, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, says that while U.S. security presence is lower than it was at the height of the Iraq war, there are some "30,000 to 40,000 U.S. troops in the region, dozens of bases, including several large military facilities, pre-positioned stocks, and security force assistance is extensive in the region." She told a Carnegie seminar that "about 54% of arms sales to Middle East come from the U.S."
"The U.S. hasn't pulled back entirely from its more diplomatic role. There are new security alignments,' said Kavanagh. One of the biggest changes is that Russia and China are playing a bigger role. It's less about a withdrawal of the United States and more about a shift in relative power. The U.S. is currently putting more force in the region. In some dimensions, they are actually doing more."
Kavanagh says China's conventional military presence in the Middle East is very small, while its economic activities are huge. Russia has a historic military presence in Syria, but it can't deliver on weapons deals given its war in Ukraine.
Frederic Wehrey, also a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, told the seminar that although China has a "reach and influence in the region, it shouldn't be blown out of proportion."
"China and Russia do offer something to the region's states. This is supplementing, not supplanting the U.S. role,' Wehrey said. 'Can these outside powers really offer the sorts of security guarantees for their partners' defense that the U.S. has provided? The answer is no. They don't have the capability or the will. China's agreements are non-binding. The U.S. is still fulfilling that primary security role."
Other observers like F. Gregory Gause, chair of international relations at the Bush School of Government and Public Service at Texas A&M University, has argued that the "debate on U.S. policy in the Middle East needs to move away from abstractions like "commitment" versus "withdrawal" and engage with the real questions of just what interests in the Middle East justify the presence of U.S. military force and what threats justify its use.
That notion becomes more relevant as Gulf Arab states work out their rapprochement with arch-foe Iran in a newly brokered Chinese deal.
Get a daily dose of Chicago Chronicle news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Chicago Chronicle.
More InformationPYONGYANG, North Korea: North Korea attempt failed to launch a satellite on May 31, which prompted raid sirens and a ...
HONG KONG, China: Describing the lack of women in China's top leadership as concerning, the United Nations has recommended the ...
BEIJING, China: Amid its rivalry with the US for reaching new milestones in space, reflecting their competition for global influence, ...
WASHINGTON D.C.: A Transportation Security Administration (TSA) report released this week revealed that over the Memorial Day weekend, the start ...
KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia: Malaysia's maritime agency has said that it found a cannon shell believed to be from World War ...
KATHMANDU, Nepal - For the past three days, agitated students and guardians have been protesting against the school administration at ...
GOWER, Missouri: Hundreds of people flocked to the small town of Gower, Missouri, to see a mummified nun, Sister Wilhelmina ...
LOUISVILLE, Kentucky: Two horses that succumbed to their injuries at Churchill Downs have become the 11th and 12th fatalities over ...
DETROIT, Michigan: After Ford Motor Co announced an agreement with Tesla to allow autos to be charged using the Tesla ...
Could Saturday night's game be the one that snaps the San Diego Padres out of their season-long doldrums? Padres manager ...
Matthew Boyd's second stint with the Detroit Tigers hasn't gone as smoothly as he envisioned, but he will look to ...
A benevolent official scorer perhaps kept the Los Angeles Angels from adding to their major-league-worst mark of 31 unearned runs ...